True Grit Rating: Calamity Jane
Loading the ticket…
Calamity Jane is a 1953 American musical Western directed by David Butler, starring Doris Day as Calamity Jane and Howard Keel as Wild Bill Hickok. Warner Bros. made it as a colourful answer to MGM's Annie Get Your Gun. It is only loosely based on Calamity Jane's life; the songs and comedy come first. The ballad "Secret Love" won the Academy Award for Best Original Song. On The Frontier Wiki it is kept as a named classic.
Plot
In Deadwood, the loud, buckskin-clad Calamity Jane boasts, shoots and rides with the boys, and pines — without quite admitting it — for Wild Bill Hickok. When the town demands a proper actress for the theatre, Calamity fetches Katie Brown from Chicago. Katie is not the star the miners expected, but she softens Deadwood and Calamity alike. Romantic mix-ups follow: Calamity thinks she loves Lieutenant Gilmartin; Bill and Katie draw together; pride and tomboy manners get in the way. By the end Calamity puts on a dress, sings "Secret Love", and finds that the man she wanted was Bill all along.
History and fiction
The real Martha Jane Canary — Calamity Jane — was a frontierswoman, scout and storyteller whose own accounts were often tall tales. Wild Bill Hickok knew Deadwood and was killed there in 1876; any romance with Calamity is legend more than proven fact. The film happily chooses legend: Day's Calamity is comic, warm and clean-cut beside the rougher historical figure. Watch it as a musical of the mythic West, not as biography.
Production and reception
Sammy Fain and Paul Francis Webster wrote the songs; "Secret Love" became one of Day's signature hits. The picture was a popular success and remains a favourite of classic Hollywood musical fans. Its bright Technicolor Deadwood and Day's energy are the main attractions.
Key facts
- Released: 1953
- Director: David Butler
- Stars: Doris Day, Howard Keel, Allyn Ann McLerie
- Setting: Deadwood, Dakota Territory (musical fantasy)
- Running time: 97 minutes
- IMDb rating: 7.2 (data)
- Directed by David Butler
Cast
See also
If you liked this
Picked from this wiki's own links: same film series, same director, same lead actor.
Frontier folk
This film is listed on: Frontier wives, mothers and widows · Blacksmiths, railroad workers and prospectors (all Frontier folk)
Gallery 2


True Grit RatingWhat's this?Woke: None found★★★★★SVLIMDb ★7.2
True Grit score: 84/100, Silver
How the score is worked out:
- Start100
- History rewritten: yes−15
- Traditional values: 3 stars+9
- Not a classic Western (comedy Western): capped at Silver: 94 → 84
- True Grit score84 · Silver
Classic Western checks
1 of 5 yes · Mostly classic
- Called “revisionist”NoNo: reviews describe it as a conventional, traditional Western rather than a revisionist one.[1][2]
- Settlers or cavalry as villainsNoNo: the villains are individuals, a gang, a boss, a posse or a cattle baron, not settlers or soldiers as a group.[1]
- Faith shown negativelyNoThe plot shows no clergy or faith portrayed negatively.[3]
- History rewrittenYesThe film's central romance between Calamity Jane and Wild Bill Hickok departs from the record: the two were acquainted, but no evidence shows they were ever … [2][4][5][6]
more
The film's central romance between Calamity Jane and Wild Bill Hickok departs from the record: the two were acquainted, but no evidence shows they were ever romantically involved. Jane herself reportedly boasted that she and Hickok were married. - A people shown as villainsNoNo: the villains are individuals, a gang or a specific war party, not a people as a whole. [7][8][2]
more
No: the villains are individuals, a gang or a specific war party, not a people as a whole. Sources describe Native Americans shown in a racist, stereotyped way.
Woke content (modern messaging)
None found0 of 8 items found so far
Show all 8 (3 not found · 5 not known)
Unless noted: Unknown.
- Characters recast for representationNot knownPortrays real people (Calamity Jane and Wild Bill Hickok).
- Gender roles reversed or critiquedNot knownOne review says Calamity's bucking of the female stereotypes of the time lends the film a feminist slant, though she is seen as more worthy …[8]
- Present-day political languageNot known
- Allegory for current politicsNot foundReleased in 1953, before the 21st-century debates this item covers, so it cannot be an allegory of them.[3]
- Western civilisation framed as inherently guiltyNot known
- Environmental activismNot foundNo: no source raises an environmental message (5 Nov 2026).[3]
- Source material changed for messagingNot foundAn original screenplay (no novel, earlier film or established characters), so there is no source to change.[3]
- LGBT or gender-identity themesNot knownSome lesbian audiences read Calamity as a lesbian character, and one critic points to lesbian overtones in her being played as a strong …[3]
Traditional values
★★★★★3/5[8]
From one parents' guide's positive messages and role models ratings: positive messages some (3) and positive role models a little (2); average 2.5, rounded to …
Content guide
- SSex & nudityMildMild sex, romance and nudity (2/5 in one parents' guide).[8]
- Sexual violence or threatNone[9]
- VViolenceModerateModerate violence and scariness (3/5 in one parents' guide).[8]
- LLanguageModerateModerate language (3/5 in one parents' guide).[8]
- StereotypesYesStereotyped portrayals of Native Americans and racist terms used for them (noted in one parents' guide).[8]
UK classification advice lists no sex or nudity issues.
Certificates: BBFC U FSK FSK 6
NoneMildModerateStrongNot known
Audience
★ 7.2/10 from viewers on IMDb (12k votes)No deduction (5.0 and up).
Sources
- Dennis Schwartz Reviews: Dennis Schwartz review
- The Guardian: Guardian (Bradshaw) (7 April 2016)
- Wikipedia: Calamity Jane (plot)
- AFI Catalog: Calamity Jane (1953) (accessed 26 October 2026)
- National Geographic, “Calamity Jane: legend and reality” (accessed 26 October 2026)
- HistoryNet, “Calamity Jane and Wild Bill Hickok” (accessed 26 October 2026)
- Once Upon a Time in a Western: Calamity Jane
- Common Sense Media: Calamity Jane
- bbfc.co.uk/release/calamity-jane-q29sbgvjdglvbjpwwc0ynzk1ntm
Information courtesy of IMDb (https://www.imdb.com). IMDb rating as of 13 October 2026.
Checked 18 October 2026 · Reviewed by Frontier Editor
Member reviews
What members think. Member reviews never change the True Grit score. The True Grit score is worked out by the editors from sources.
Sources
- Calamity Jane (1953 film) - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1228404 wikidata.org
- Wikimedia Commons: Calamity Jane trailer.jpg commons.wikimedia.org
- Calamity Jane American film - Britannica britannica.com
- IMDb Non-Commercial Datasets developer.imdb.com
- Calamity jane q29sbgvjdglvbjpwwc0ynzk1ntm - bbfc.co.uk bbfc.co.uk
- Rotten Tomatoes (score via Wikidata) rottentomatoes.com
- Wikimedia Commons: Calamity Jane LCCN2005688173.jpg commons.wikimedia.org
- Wikimedia Commons: Calamity Jane%2C Gen. Crook%27s scout LCCN2016649829.jpg commons.wikimedia.org





