TheFrontierWiki
An almanac of the American West on page & screen
Sign in
Films › Some Liar

Some Liar (1919)

Directed by Henry King

Genres: Comedy Westerns

Your rating

Sign in free to save films, rate them and make lists.

Some Liar1919 · FilmPoster coming soon

Photo: American Film Company / Pathé Distributors · Public domain · source

Some Liar (1919) is a silent comedy Western directed by Henry King, starring William Russell as Robert Winchester McTabb, a tall-tale-telling salesman of coffins and cradles in Yellow Jacket, Arizona, with Eileen Percy.

Cast

William RussellRobert Winchester McTabb
Eileen Percy
Eileen PercyCelie Sterling
Heywood MackSheldon Lewis Kellard

If you liked this

Picked from this wiki's own links: same film series, same director, same lead actor.

Key facts

True Grit 84, Silver, provisional848484True Grit RatingWhat's this?SVLProvisional

True Grit score: 84/100, Silver Provisional

How the score is worked out:

  • Start100
  • Provisional, capped at Silver: 100 → 84 (3 checks not known, provisional)
  • Presumed (silent era, 1910–1929): sex & nudity, violence, language, faith shown negatively presumed no, counted as checked0
  • True Grit score84 · Silver

Classic Western checks

1 of 4 yes · Mostly classic · 1 not known

  • Called “revisionist”YesYes: comedy / parody Western (R7).[1]
  • Settlers or cavalry as villainsNot knownUnknown.
  • Faith shown negativelyPresumed noPresumed no (silent era)
  • History rewrittenNoSource gives the plot: French Wikipedia (Un fameux lascar, revision 230185493, retrieved 2026-11-06T12:58:11Z) plot section, quoted in the original French.
    moreSource gives the plot: French Wikipedia (Un fameux lascar, revision 230185493, retrieved 2026-11-06T12:58:11Z) plot section, quoted in the original French. English summary (ours, not a quotation): Tall-tale-telling salesman Robert Winchester McTabb arrives in Yellow Jacket, Arizona, selling coffins and cradles. No true-story claim found on the page. history_rewritten no = owner true-story gate (H2; H3/H4 where real names or events appear only as backdrop) applied to that: an inference under the owner rule, not a statement by the source. Citation audit 2026-11-06.
    [2]

Content guide

  • SSex & nudityPresumed no
  • VViolencePresumed no
  • LLanguagePresumed no

Presumed no (silent era)

NoneMildModerateStrongNot known

How well sourced: 2 sources (1 independent; Wikipedia and Wikidata count as one). See sources.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Some Liar
  2. Wikipedia (fr): Un fameux lascar (plot section, original French) (checked 24 October 2026)

Checked 24 October 2026 · Reviewed by Frontier Editor

Provisional: not enough sources yet, so this rating may change.

How the rating works →

Member reviews

What members think. Member reviews never change the True Grit score. The True Grit score is worked out by the editors from sources.

Sources

  1. Some Liar - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikidata: Q3489778 wikidata.org
  3. Wikimedia Commons: Some Liar (1919) - Ad 1.jpg commons.wikimedia.org