✦ Legend
Yes. Sheriff Pat Garrett shot Billy the Kid dead at Pete Maxwell's ranch house in Fort Sumner, New Mexico Territory, on the night of 14 July 1881. Garrett's report to the territorial governor was printed in newspapers later that month, and the Kid is buried at Fort Sumner. Later claims that he survived have never been proven.Sources: Young Gun, Library of Congress blog Timeless, 20 April 2015 (accessed 27 October 2026) · Billy the Kid | Biography, Encyclopaedia Britannica (accessed 27 October 2026)
Billy the Kid was the name the newspapers gave to Henry McCarty (1859–1881), who also went by Kid Antrim and, from 1877, William H. Bonney. He was a young cattle rustler and gunfighter in New Mexico Territory who took part in the Lincoln County War. He was shot dead by Sheriff Pat Garrett at Fort Sumner in July 1881, aged about 21. Few figures of the Old West have so short a real career and so long an afterlife: more than 50 films have been made about him, and the legend has often drowned out the record.
Early life
McCarty was born in New York City to Irish Catholic parents. The year, 1859, is accepted, but the exact date is disputed: accounts give either 17 September or 23 November, with 23 November more common but doubted. His mother, Catherine, moved west with her sons and in 1873 married William Antrim in Santa Fe. The family settled in Silver City, New Mexico, where she died of tuberculosis in September 1874. Antrim left, and the boys were effectively orphaned.
First crimes
In September 1875 McCarty was arrested for stealing food, and ten days later for a theft from a Chinese laundry. He escaped from jail two days after that, and the Silver City Herald ran the first newspaper story about him. He drifted into Arizona Territory, worked as a ranch hand and stole horses from soldiers near Camp Grant. In August 1877 he shot and mortally wounded a blacksmith, Francis "Windy" Cahill, during a fight in a saloon at Bonita. He escaped custody again and fled back to New Mexico.
The Lincoln County War
In New Mexico he joined the Regulators, one side in the Lincoln County War of 1878, a violent feud between rival business factions. He and two other Regulators were charged with killing three men, including Lincoln County Sheriff William J. Brady and one of his deputies. His fame grew sharply in December 1880, when the Las Vegas Gazette and New York's The Sun carried stories about him, and that month Pat Garrett captured him.
Conviction, escape and death
In April 1881 he was tried and convicted of Brady's murder and sentenced to hang. On 28 April he escaped from the Lincoln County jail, killing two deputies. He stayed free for more than two months. Late on 14 July 1881, at Pete Maxwell's house in Fort Sumner, he walked into a darkened bedroom where Garrett was waiting and was shot dead.
Legend versus history
- The body count. Legend inflated the number of men he killed. Accounts differ: some link him to nine killings, only four of them by him alone; others say the true number was probably fewer than ten.
- Did he survive? Rumours spread that Garrett had faked the killing so his friend could escape. Several men later claimed to be the Kid, most famously "Brushy Bill" Roberts of Hico, Texas, in 1948, and John Miller of Arizona. Neither claim has been proved. Attempts to settle the question with DNA in the 2000s produced no conclusive evidence.
- Left-handed? His only authenticated photograph, a small ferrotype taken around 1879–80, shows his revolver on his left hip. That led to the belief that he was left-handed, but ferrotypes produce a reversed image. His handedness is disputed: historians have argued he was right-handed, and some say he was ambidextrous. The ferrotype sold at auction in 2011 for $2.3 million.
- Other photographs. A tintype said to show him playing croquet with the Regulators surfaced in 2010. Its authenticity is disputed: some experts accepted it, while New Mexico state monument officials said they could not confirm it.
- The pardon. In 2010 New Mexico Governor Bill Richardson refused a posthumous pardon, which supporters said would honour a promise made to the Kid by Governor Lew Wallace in 1879. Richardson cited "historical ambiguity".
Much of the early legend came from The Authentic Life of Billy, the Kid (1882), written by Garrett with Ash Upson. It was full of errors but remained the main source for books about him until the 1960s.
On screen
The Kid has been portrayed in more than 50 films. They include Billy the Kid Returns (1938), Chisum (1970), Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (1973), Young Guns (1988), Young Guns II (1990) and The Kid (2019). He is also among the figures depicted in The Life and Times of Judge Roy Bean (1972).
Key facts
- Born: 1859 (date disputed), New York City, US
- Died: 14 July 1881, Fort Sumner, New Mexico Territory
- Also known as: Henry McCarty, Kid Antrim, William H. Bonney
- Known for: Lincoln County War; escape from Lincoln jail, 1881
- Killed by: Sheriff Pat Garrett
- Born 1859 in New York City (Britannica: 23 November 1859, with doubts); died 14 July 1881, Fort Sumner, New Mexico
- Wikipedia links him to nine killings, four of them by him alone; Britannica says probably fewer than ten
- Escaped jail on 28 April 1881, killing two deputies (Britannica)
- Shot dead by Pat Garrett (Wikipedia, Britannica)
See also
Questions and answers
Who was Billy the Kid?
As a boy he was known as Henry McCarty; later he used the name William H. Bonney, and historians still debate which was his real name. He drifted into theft and gang life in the South-west. Pat Garrett captured him in December 1880. He was tried at Mesilla in April 1881, found guilty of murder and sentenced to hang, but on 28 April he escaped from jail, killing two deputies.
Sources: Billy the Kid | Biography, Encyclopaedia Britannica (accessed 27 October 2026) · Today in History – April 28, Library of Congress (link not checked yet)
How many people did Billy the Kid kill?
Far fewer than the legend says. He was said to have claimed 21 killings, but Encyclopaedia Britannica puts the real number at probably fewer than ten.
Sources: Billy the Kid | Biography, Encyclopaedia Britannica (accessed 27 October 2026)
How did Billy the Kid die?
Pat Garrett tracked him to Fort Sumner and shot him dead at Pete Maxwell's ranch house late on 14 July 1881. He is buried at Fort Sumner. Garrett's report to the governor was printed in newspapers that month, and in 1882 Garrett published a book about the Kid, largely written by his friend Ash Upson.
Sources: Young Gun, Library of Congress blog Timeless, 20 April 2015 (accessed 27 October 2026) · Billy the Kid | Biography, Encyclopaedia Britannica (accessed 27 October 2026)
Was Brushy Bill Roberts really Billy the Kid?
That's a legend, not history. One theory says the Kid escaped and lived on as Ollie L. "Brushy Bill" Roberts, who died at Hico, Texas, in 1950. It has never been proven, and the record from 1881, including Garrett's report and the grave at Fort Sumner, points to the Kid dying there.
Sources: Billy the Kid | Biography, Encyclopaedia Britannica (accessed 27 October 2026) · Young Gun, Library of Congress blog Timeless, 20 April 2015 (accessed 27 October 2026)
Gallery 8








In the films 4




Sources
- Billy the Kid - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q44200 wikidata.org
- Billy the Kid American outlaw - Britannica britannica.com
- Wikimedia Commons: Billy the Kid corrected.jpg commons.wikimedia.org

