True Grit Rating
Film, TV and book pages carry a True Grit Rating box near the top. Closed, it shows one line: the overall True Grit score as a sheriff's star (or a lump of coal below 40) once the title has been checked, “Woke” with the level of woke content (modern messaging), the traditional values stars, three small letter boxes for the content guide, the IMDb audience score, and a Provisional tag if the rating is not settled (or a Partly checked tag if some checks are still not known). Click it to open the full detail, with every source linked. A page only has a box once something about the title has been checked; some pages so far have only the content guide or the audience score.
Reading the box
The content letters are S sex and nudity, V violence and L language. The colour of each box shows the level (hover or tap for the words):
NoneMildModerateStrongNot known
Opened, the box reads from top to bottom:
- Score: the badge and how the score is worked out, step by step.
- Classic Western checks: the five questions, each Yes, No or Not known, with a one-line note, plus a “Christian faith shown well” or “Another belief promoted” line where there is one.
- Woke content: the level and only the items found; the rest are under “Show all 8”.
- Traditional values: the stars and a short note.
- Content guide: sex and nudity, violence and language, with the same coloured letters, plus sexual violence and stereotypes notes where there are any.
- Audience: the IMDb rating.
- Sources: numbered; the small [1] [2] links in each section point to them. Then the small print: the IMDb credit, when it was checked and who reviewed it.
Sections with nothing in them are left out.
1. Classic Western score (0–5)
Five questions, each answered yes, no or not known. For the first question a “yes” needs one cited source; for the other four it needs three independent sources (the site's rule for claims about how people and groups are shown). With fewer, the answer is “not known”. The score is the number of “yes” answers, so a lower score means fewer of these features.
- Called “revisionist” by a reliable source
- Settlers, cowboys or cavalry shown as the villains as a group
- Faith shown negatively (Christians or clergy mocked or villainised)
- Documented history rewritten (noted by historians or reviewers)
- An ethnic, national or religious people shown as villains as a group
The question about a people shown as villains covers an ethnic, national or religious people (for example a tribe, Mexicans, Chinese or Mormons) shown as the enemy as a group, as faceless savages or bandits. One villain from a group does not count.
This check marks down films that make American settlers or the American army the villains; foreign armies, outlaws and raiders count as traditional villains.
The label counts the first four questions; a people shown as villains costs points but does not change the label.
The first and the history question are kept apart on purpose: the first is about outlook, the history question about factual accuracy.
- 0 Classic Western
- 1 Mostly classic
- 2 Mixed
- 3 Revisionist-leaning
- 4 Heavily revisionist
2. Woke content (modern messaging)
Eight kinds of present-day messaging, each answered yes, no or not known. A “yes” needs a verbatim quote from a reliable source (a professional review, the trade press, a creator or studio interview, a historian, or an established family or faith review outlet). A “no” needs one reliable source (for a “no” that is true by definition, for example a film set in the present day cannot be an allegory for current politics, or an original screenplay has no source to change, that source just shows the basic fact). The finished work is what counts: a stated intention is not a “yes” unless a review confirms it is on screen. Historically accurate casting, or a diverse cast on its own, never counts.
- Characters recast for representation
- Gender roles reversed or critiqued
- Present-day political language
- Allegory for current politics
- Western civilisation framed as inherently guilty
- Environmental activism
- Source material changed for messaging
- LGBT or gender-identity themes
The level is worked out from the answers and shown with the count, for example “Some (2 of 8)”: Some means 1–2 yes; Heavy means 3 or more, or one theme that a cited source calls central to the work; None means every item is a sourced no; None found means no yes so far but some items are not yet known; Not known means nothing has been checked yet.
Nothing is counted twice: a finding that is already one of the five checks above (for example, settlers shown as the villains) is marked “covered by Part 1” and not counted again here. Faith stays in Part 1 only. Websites that publish their own “woke” scores are used only to find leads and are never cited.
3. Traditional values (0–5 stars)
How well the title shows family, faith, courage, justice and honour. This counts in the title’s favour and is shown on its own: it is not added to or taken from the parts above. It needs a source or a sourced justification.
4. Content guide
Sex and nudity, violence, and language (swearing, including blasphemy), each rated None, Mild, Moderate or Strong, shown as a coloured S, V or L box (see the key above), from sources such as Kids-in-Mind, Common Sense Media, the IMDb Parents Guide and the BBFC. Sexual violence or threat, age certificates and notes from our earlier content advice are shown here too, and so is a Stereotypes note where a content source flags stereotyped portrayals (shown for information only; it does not change the score).
Audience score
Where we have one, the box also shows the title's IMDb user rating and vote count, e.g. “★ 7.8/10 from viewers on IMDb (88k votes)”. It is what viewers think of the title as a whole. It is shown in its own section and plays no part in the Classic Western checks, the woke content level or the stars; a low rating does take points off the overall True Grit score (below). A page with only an audience score still gets the box, so every title has the same component. Information courtesy of IMDb (https://www.imdb.com).
The True Grit score (out of 100)
Once a title has been checked (at least one Part 1 question or messaging item answered yes or no), the box shows an overall score as a sheriff's star (or a lump of coal below 40). It starts at 100 and uses only answers that meet the sourcing rules:
- Classic Western score: −15 for each “yes”. “Called revisionist” only costs points for a title that claims to be based on a true story.
- Woke content: Some −35, Heavy −60 (None, None found and Not known: no change). Titles from before 2000: not scored; the warning still shows.
- LGBT or gender-identity theme found (a sourced “yes”, central or not) on a title from 2000 on: automatic Coal (score 0), whatever the other steps add up to, and the badge says “Coal: LGBT content”. Titles from before 2000: the warning shows, no change. A title named as an exception (currently The Harder They Fall, 2021) keeps its normal score and the warning. The title always stays on the site.
- Traditional values: +3 per star, up to +15.
- Content: Strong sex and nudity −10; Graphic violence (gory, sadistic or lingering cruelty) −10, waived for titles rated 7.0 or higher on IMDb, with a good story or positive reviews; Strong language −5. Ordinary violence and lower levels do not count.
- Modern soundtrack (contemporary or anachronistic music in a period Western, with a sourced yes): −10, for titles of any year. Not known or no: no change.
- Christian faith shown positively +10. A film that promotes another belief system (for example Latter-day Saints, Jehovah’s Witness or Native American spiritual beliefs) −10.
- IMDb audience rating: below 5.0 −10; 5.0 and up, no change. No rating, no change.
The total is kept between 0 and 100 and rounded. Anything “Not known” is left out of the score: it counts neither for nor against the title. A true-story title that a reliable source calls “revisionist” (a Part 1 “yes”) can't reach Gold: its score is capped at Silver (84).
Two other cases are capped at Silver (84) until they are settled: a provisional rating (not enough sources yet), and a title that claims to be based on a true story but has no answer yet for “Called revisionist” or “History rewritten”. When a cap applies, the breakdown says so. A title with checks still “Not known” carries a small Partly checked tag for information only. Films released before 2000 count as fully checked even with “Not known” on the woke content items. True Grit (1969) is the standard film and scores 100.
- Diamond: 100, a perfect score, shown as a faceted diamond star. Only the very best reach it (see “What it takes to be Diamond” below).
- Gold: 85–99, for exceptional titles.
- Silver: 65–84 (good).
- Bronze: 40–64 (caution).
- Coal: below 40, shown as a lump of coal instead of a star.
- Diamond
100 - Gold
85–99 - Silver
65–84 - Bronze
40–64 - Coal
under 40 - Provisional
matte, no shine
Open the box to see each deduction and bonus. A page with only a content guide or audience score has no badge. A provisional rating's star has a matte finish with no shine and is labelled Provisional; a provisional lump of coal has a dashed outline.
Only classic Westerns reach Gold or Diamond
Gold and Diamond are kept for classic Westerns: stories set in the Old West and told straight. A title of one of these kinds is capped at 84, Silver, however well it scores otherwise:
- comedy Westerns, and spoofs or parodies that make fun of Western life;
- satire;
- fantasy, including science fiction and time travel (Back to the Future Part III counts as both fantasy and comedy), and horror Westerns with supernatural or monster stories;
- space Westerns;
- present-day (modern-setting) Westerns.
We go by the kind of Western a title is listed as. When a title isn't listed as any kind, it counts as classic unless its description clearly says otherwise. Made-up revisionist stories and novel adaptations still count as classic. When the cap applies, the breakdown says “Not a classic Western: capped at Silver”. Hints of the supernatural are fine as long as they are not the whole theme of the film (Pale Rider counts as classic).
Poorly reviewed titles are Bronze
In the words of the site's owner: “bronze applies only when all three ratings — Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and IMDb — are each below 50 per cent”, and for titles where we don't have all three, “make them Bronze on the ratings we have”. We compare the Rotten Tomatoes score, the Metacritic score and the IMDb rating times ten, using whichever of them we have. When every one we have is under 50, the title shows Bronze, with its score set to the average of those ratings, kept within Bronze (40–64). Ratings we don't have are left out. The rule never raises a score, and a title already in Coal stays Coal. If any rating we have is 50 or more, nothing changes. The separate IMDb-under-5 deduction (−10) still applies. The breakdown says, for example, “Poorly reviewed (IMDb 4.7, RT 12%, MC 33): Bronze”.
What it takes to be Diamond
A title that adds up to 100 is only shown as Diamond if all five of these are true. If any one is not, it shows 99, Gold instead, and the breakdown says which check it missed.
- Its score before it is kept within 0–100 is at least as high as True Grit (1969)'s (109). True Grit (1969) is the standard and stays Diamond.
- It is rated 7.0 or higher on IMDb, from at least 10,000 votes.
- Its sex and nudity, violence and language ratings are all known.
- It is a classic Western in story and period. Comedy or spoof Westerns, present-day (modern-setting) Westerns, and fantasy, horror or space Westerns don't count.
- It is not a true-story film that is called revisionist or that rewrites history. Made-up stories and novel adaptations that critics call revisionist are fine.
If a title misses Diamond only because the IMDb votes or a content rating aren't known yet, it carries a small Needs data tag. It may move up to Diamond once that is filled in.
Provisional ratings
A rating marked Provisional does not have enough sources yet and may change as more are found. A provisional title is never counted as fully checked, so it can't go above Silver (84).
Fair and factual
The wording is kept factual and fair. Ratings are about what reliable sources say about a title, and each box shows when it was checked and who reviewed it. Personal verdicts are not part of the rating.
