At dawn on 29 November 1864, around 700 Colorado volunteer cavalry under Colonel John M. Chivington attacked the camp of Black Kettle's and White Antelope's Southern Cheyenne and Left Hand's Arapaho on Sand Creek, Colorado Territory. Congress, an Army commission and the 1865 treaty all condemned the attack as a massacre. Period estimates of the dead range from about 70 to about 500.Sources: Massacre of Cheyenne Indians (Report of the Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War, 38th Cong., 2nd Sess.), U.S. Congress / Government Printing Office, 1865 (accessed 27 October 2026) · Sand Creek Massacre: Report of the Secretary of War… evidence taken at Denver and Fort Lyon… by a military commission (Senate Ex. Doc. No. 26, 39th Cong., 2nd Sess.), U.S. Senate / War Department, 1867 (testimony 1865) (accessed 27 October 2026) · Treaty with the Cheyenne and Arapaho, 1865 (Treaty of the Little Arkansas), 14 Stat. 703, Oklahoma State University Libraries (accessed 27 October 2026) · Timeline – Sand Creek Massacre National Historic Site, National Park Service, 2024-04-22 (last updated) (accessed 27 October 2026)
Summary
Raids, murders and captive-taking in 1864 left Colorado settlers believing the territory was at war [1][2]. Black Kettle and other chiefs sought peace and camped near Fort Lyon believing they were treated as friendly [1][2]. Congress found that the people under Black Kettle, White Antelope and Left Hand "were and had been friendly to the whites" and called the attack "a foul and dastardly massacre" [1]. This page uses the word massacre, as the 1865 congressional report, the Army commission and the 1865 treaty did [1][2][6]. Chivington and Denver's Rocky Mountain News called it "the Battle of Sand Creek" against a hostile camp, and their account is given below in their own words [1][5].
Background: the war of 1864
By the summer of 1864 the Colorado settlements were badly frightened. Acting Governor Samuel Elbert wrote that "allied and hostile tribes have attacked our frontier settlements" [1]. At the Camp Weld council in September the Cheyenne and Arapaho delegates themselves named white captives taken that summer, among them Laura Roper and Isabel Ubanks [2]. When Evans told them that "as a nation you have gone to war", they answered: "We acknowledge that our actions have given you reason to believe this" [2]. The congressional committee accepted that the Dog Soldiers "had been guilty of acts of hostility", but found that they "had no connexion with Black Kettle's band" [1].
Accounts differ on how the spring fighting began. In mid-April 1864 Lieutenant Clark Dunn's detachment was sent to recover stock said to have been taken and to disarm the Indians, and it met a Cheyenne party at Fremont's Orchard. Major Jacob Downing, giving Dunn's report, testified that "as soon as his men had dismounted the Indians fired upon them" [7]. The Cheyenne Spotted Horse, who was in the fight, said through an interpreter that Dunn's men "tried to wrest" the Indians' weapons from them, and that the Indians "were fired upon by the soldiers" [7]. At Camp Weld, Evans said the Indians "fired a volley", and White Antelope replied that "a soldier fired first" [2]. In May the Cheyenne chief Lean Bear was killed by soldiers. Major Wynkoop told the commission the Cheyenne account, which was that he "approached the column alone, with friendly feelings" [2][8]. Each side blamed the other, and this page does not settle the question.
The Hungate killings. On 11 June 1864 Nathan and Ellen Hungate and their two small daughters were killed south-east of Denver, and their mutilated bodies were shown publicly in the city [8]. Who did it was never settled. At Camp Weld the Arapaho Neva blamed a northern Arapaho party under "Medicine Man, or Roman Nose" (not the Cheyenne leader of that name). Agent Whiteley replied: "That cannot be true" [2][7]. The Rocky Mountain News claimed that "the confessed murderers of the Hungate family" fell at Sand Creek, but it named no one [5]. No period source found ties the killings to Black Kettle's or Left Hand's camp.
Evans's proclamations. On 27 June 1864 Evans told "all friendly Indians" to "keep away from those who are at war, and go to places of safety" [1]. On 11 August he authorised citizens "to kill and destroy, as enemies of the country, wherever they may be found, all such hostile Indians", while "scrupulously avoiding those who have responded to my said call" [1]. That month he was also authorised to raise the 100-day 3rd Colorado Cavalry [8].
Peace efforts: Smoky Hill, Camp Weld and Fort Lyon
In September Major Edward Wynkoop rode to the Smoky Hill River in answer to letters from Black Kettle and other chiefs, and captives were handed over [2][8]. He then brought the chiefs to Camp Weld near Denver, where they met Evans and Chivington on 28 September 1864. Black Kettle said: "All we ask is that we may have peace with the whites." Evans answered that "the power to make a treaty of peace has passed from me to the great war chief" [2]. The chiefs were directed to Fort Lyon [8].
There the people were at first given rations. When Major Scott Anthony replaced Wynkoop in November, the rations stopped, and on Anthony's suggestion the Cheyenne went to Sand Creek to hunt and wait for word from headquarters [1][8]. The interpreter John Smith, who was in the camp, described "about one hundred lodges, numbering altogether some five hundred souls, two-thirds of whom were women and children" [2].
The attack, 29 November 1864
Chivington left Fort Lyon with the 3rd Colorado and part of the 1st and rode through the night of 28 November [8]. At daybreak the troops attacked. According to the congressional report, Black Kettle "ran up to the top of his lodge an American flag… with a small white flag under it" [1]. Soule testified that "the command was scattered and every man firing on his own hook" [2].
Several period witnesses say that the dead were scalped and mutilated. Soule wrote that "they were all scalped" [3]. Lieutenant Joseph Cramer wrote of "fingers cut off to get the rings on them, and this as much with Officers as men" [4]. John Smith swore that the bodies "had been mutilated in the most horrible manner" [2]. The congressional committee agreed [1], and the London Spectator repeated its finding that "the soldiers indulged in acts of barbarity of the most revolting character" [10].
White Antelope and One Eye were killed [1]. Black Kettle escaped, though early reports counted him among the dead, and he signed the 1865 treaty as head chief [1][6]. Left Hand was badly wounded and, by most accounts, died of his wounds soon afterwards. The agent Samuel Colley testified that he "was wounded, and died after he got over there", and Jesse Leavenworth said the same from what he was told [1]. The Rocky Mountain News reported that "Colonel Chivington is of the opinion that he was not" killed [1].
Two officers who said they would not fire
Captain Silas Soule and Lieutenant Joseph Cramer of the 1st Colorado had been at the Fort Lyon talks. Cramer wrote that he had told Chivington beforehand "that I thought it murder to jump them friendly Indians" [4]. In letters to Wynkoop, Soule wrote, "I refused to fire and swore that none but a coward would" [3], and Cramer wrote, "I swore I would not burn powder, and I did not. Capt. Soule the same" [4]. In 1865 Cramer swore that "Captain Soule did not order his men to fire when the order was given to commence the fight" [7]. Before the Army commission both were more guarded: Soule said only "some firing done" [2]. Wynkoop passed the letters on, and they helped bring about the inquiries [8][9].
How many died
Period counts vary widely, so this page gives a range.
- Low: John Smith "saw altogether some seventy dead bodies" [1].
- Middle: the congressional committee found "more than one hundred dead bodies, three-fourths of them of women and children" [1]. Soule put the dead at "not more than two hundred" [3], and Cramer at "not over 200" [4].
- Chivington's side: "between five and six hundred Indians were left dead upon the field" [1]. His witness L. Meyer said he counted about 450 dead warriors [2].
Range used on this page: about 70 to about 500 Cheyenne and Arapaho dead, with Chivington's 500–600 noted. The National Park Service's modern estimate is "over 230", including about 150 women, children and elderly [8].
Chivington's side: "the Battle of Sand Creek"
Chivington swore that he attacked because "I believed the Indians in the camp were hostile to the whites", and "of the same tribes with those who had murdered many persons and destroyed much valuable property on the Platte and Arkansas rivers" [1].
On three points the evidence divides. Warriors: Chivington said the camp held "about seven hundred" warriors [1], and John Smith said "about two hundred" [1]. White scalps: Chivington swore to "the scalps of nineteen (19) white persons" [1], and witnesses he called, among them L. Meyer and T. P. Bell, said they saw white scalps [2]. Corporal Amos Miksch of the 1st Colorado "heard nothing of a fresh white scalp in the Indian camp until I saw it in the Dunn papers" [7]. Rifle pits: Meyer said they were dug before the attack [2]. Miksch said "there were no rifle-pits except what the Indians dug into the sand-bank after we commenced firing" [7]. This page states neither side as fact.
The Rocky Mountain News ranked the campaign among "the brilliant feats of arms in Indian warfare" (17 December 1864), and it called talk of a "surrendered" village "all bosh" (30 December 1864) [5]. Many Coloradans saw eastern criticism as an attack on justified self-defence [8]. The Spectator allowed that the emigrants "have most of them individual wrongs to avenge", but judged that "even with this extenuation" the committee's recommendation "appears most unworthily lenient" [10].
Inquiries and aftermath
- The Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War (1865) found that Chivington "deliberately planned and executed a foul and dastardly massacre" [1]. The New York Times printed the report on 23 July 1865 [11], and the Deseret News reprinted it on 13 September 1865 [12].
- The Army military commission, under Lieutenant Colonel Samuel F. Tappan, sat at Denver and Fort Lyon in 1865, and the Senate printed its evidence [2]. Chivington had mustered out on 6 January 1865 [8].
- The Doolittle committee (report 1867) took further testimony [7].
Soule's murder. On the night of 23 April 1865 Soule, then provost marshal, was "assassinated in the streets of Denver" [2][15]. Chivington told the commission that he "was killed by one Squires, a soldier of the second Colorado cavalry, which Squires admitted before he made his escape" [2]. The soldier is usually named as Charles W. Squiers. The killers had served under Chivington, and they escaped and were never tried [16][17].
The Treaty of the Little Arkansas (14 October 1865). In Article 6 the United States repudiated "the gross and wanton out-rages perpetrated against certain bands of Cheyenne and Arrapahoe Indians… at Sand Creek… while the said Indians were at peace with the United States, and under its flag", and it promised land to the widows and orphans [6]. The war went on regardless. In early 1865 Cheyenne, Arapaho and Lakota warriors attacked Julesburg and the Platte road in revenge [8].
A Christian reflection
The settlers' fear was real: the Hungates were butchered, and women and children were carried off from the trails [1][2]. Yet the man who led the attack was an ordained Methodist minister, presiding elder of his church's Rocky Mountain District from 1860 [7][18][19]. Two of his own officers said they would not fire on people kneeling for mercy [3][4][7]. Congress, the Army commission and the treaty of 1865 all judged that wrong was done [1][2][6], so the verdict is not modern opinion. Scripture counts "hands that shed innocent blood" among the things the Lord hates (Proverbs 6:17). Fear and grief do not excuse it, and those who refused deserve to be remembered.
Sources
- [1] Massacre of Cheyenne Indians (Report of the Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War, 38th Cong., 2nd Sess.). U.S. Congress / Government Printing Office (scan: Internet Archive), 1865. https://archive.org/details/massacreofcheyen00unit
- [2] Sand Creek Massacre: Report of the Secretary of War… evidence taken at Denver and Fort Lyon… by a military commission (Senate Ex. Doc. No. 26, 39th Cong., 2nd Sess.). U.S. Senate / War Department (scan: Internet Archive), 1867 (testimony 1865). https://archive.org/details/GR_4292
- [3] Silas Soule, letter to Maj. Edward Wynkoop, 14 Dec 1864 (as reproduced in "The Life of Silas Soule"). National Park Service (letter text), 1864-12-14 (page updated 2025-04-24). https://www.nps.gov/sand/learn/historyculture/the-life-of-silas-soule.htm
- [4] Joseph Cramer, letter to Maj. Edward Wynkoop, 19 Dec 1864 ("The Sand Creek Massacre Letters"). RootsWeb (transcription from Deborah Frazier, Rocky Mountain News, 15 Sept 2000), 1864-12-19. https://freepages.rootsweb.com/~wynkoop/genealogy/webdocs/sndcrklt.htm
- [5] Rocky Mountain News editorials "The Battle of Sand Creek" (reprinted in JCCW report). Rocky Mountain News, Denver (ed. William N. Byers), via JCCW, 1864-12-17 and 1864-12-30. Text from the reprint in [1], pp. 56–58. https://archive.org/details/massacreofcheyen00unit
- [6] Treaty with the Cheyenne and Arapaho, 1865 (Treaty of the Little Arkansas), 14 Stat. 703. Oklahoma State University Libraries (Kappler), 1865-10-14. https://treaties.okstate.edu/treaties/treaty-with-the-cheyenne-and-arapaho-1865-0887
- [7] Condition of the Indian Tribes: Report of the Joint Special Committee (Doolittle committee), with appendix. U.S. Congress / GPO (scan: Internet Archive / Google), 1867-01-26. Appendix: Downing pp. 68–69; Bouser (Spotted Horse) pp. 72–73; Cramer p. 73; Miksch pp. 74–75; Wynkoop p. 74; Willard (Denver, 27 Jul 1865). https://archive.org/details/conditionindian00tribgoog
- [8] Timeline – Sand Creek Massacre National Historic Site. National Park Service, 2024-04-22 (last updated). https://www.nps.gov/sand/learn/timeline.htm
- [9] The Life of Silas Soule. National Park Service, 2025-04-24 (last updated). https://www.nps.gov/sand/learn/historyculture/the-life-of-silas-soule.htm
- [10] "The Times correspondent reports a horrible story…". The Spectator (London), 1865-08-12. https://archive.spectator.co.uk/article/12th-august-1865/2/the-times-correspondent-reports-a-horrible-story-a
- [11] "Our Indian Troubles; Report of the Committee on the Conduct of the War on the Massacre of Cheyenne Indians". The New York Times, 1865-07-23. (full page not opened)
- [12] "The Chivington Massacre: Report of the Committee on the Conduct of the War". Deseret News (Salt Lake City), reprinted from a Washington paper, 1865-09-13. https://newspapers.lib.utah.edu/details?id=2598596
- [15] "The Homicide Last Night". Rocky Mountain News, Denver (transcription by kclonewolf.com), 1865-04-24. (original issue not opened)
- [16] Behind the Marker at 15th and Arapahoe: The Life of Silas Soule. Denver Public Library, n.d. https://history.denverlibrary.org/news/behind-marker-15th-and-arapahoe-life-silas-soule
- [17] Denver Westerners Roundup, vol. 61 no. 4. Denver Posse of Westerners, 2005. https://npshistory.com/publications/sand/dwr-v61n4-2005.pdf
- [18] United Methodists plan Sand Creek project (Linda Bloom). UMNews / United Methodist Communications, 2013-04-04. https://www.umnews.org/en/news/united-methodists-plan-sand-creek-project
- [19] John M. Chivington: The "Reverend Colonel"… Nebraska History (History Nebraska), 2007. https://history.nebraska.gov/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/doc_publications_NH2007Chivington.pdf
Key facts
- The attack began at dawn on 29 November 1864, after an overnight ride from Fort Lyon.
- About 700 men of the 100-day 3rd Colorado Cavalry and part of the 1st Colorado took part.
- According to the congressional report, Black Kettle raised an American flag with a small white flag beneath it over his lodge.
- White Antelope and One Eye were killed; Black Kettle escaped; Left Hand was badly wounded and, by most accounts, died of his wounds.
- Period counts of the dead range from about 70 to about 500; the National Park Service's modern estimate is over 230, including about 150 women, children and elderly people.
- Captain Silas Soule and Lieutenant Joseph Cramer wrote that they would not fire on the camp; their letters helped bring about the inquiries.
- Three inquiries followed: the Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War, an Army military commission and the Doolittle committee.
- Soule was shot dead in Denver on 23 April 1865; his killers escaped and were never tried.
- In the Treaty of the Little Arkansas (14 October 1865) the United States repudiated the attack and promised land to the widows and orphans.
