TheFrontierWiki
An almanac of the American West on page & screen
Sign in
Old West › Posse comitatus

Posse comitatus

✦ ✦ ✦
How well sourced: 2 sources (1 independent; Wikipedia and Wikidata count as one). See sources.

The posse comitatus, Latin for "the force of the county", is the old common-law power of a sheriff or other officer to call on able-bodied local people to help keep the peace or catch a criminal. Shortened to posse, it gave the Western one of its most familiar sights: a band of armed townsmen riding hard out of town behind the sheriff, on the trail of bank robbers or rustlers.

An English idea

The posse comitatus goes back to 9th-century England, when the king's local officers, the reeves and later the sheriffs, could call out the men of the shire to keep the king's peace. Over the centuries English law kept the duty of every person to come "at the command of the sheriff and at the cry of the country" to arrest a felon, and the Sheriffs Act of 1887 still fined people who refused. That part of the law was only repealed in 1967.

From the mid-17th century the short form "posse" came to mean the group of men itself rather than the legal power, and later any armed band at all.

The posse in the American West

English settlers took the idea to America, where it became a tool of local self-government: the posse worked only because ordinary citizens agreed to turn out. On the frontier, where a county might have one sheriff and a deputy or two for thousands of square miles, the posse was often the only way to chase an outlaw gang. Federal US marshals had the same power, granted by the Judiciary Act of 1789, to swear in civilians as deputies "for necessary assistance".

Some examples from Old West history:

  • In 1878 Pima County Sheriff Charles Shibell and a citizen posse ran down and killed the masked stagecoach robber William Brazelton near Tucson.
  • In March 1882 Wyatt Earp, then a deputy US marshal, led a federal posse after the men he blamed for his brother Morgan's murder, while Cochise County Sheriff Johnny Behan raised a rival posse to pursue them (see Cochise County Cowboys).
  • In 1876 the townsfolk of Northfield, Minnesota, and the posses that followed, broke up the James–Younger Gang after its failed bank raid.

Posse or mob?

The line between a lawful posse and a lynch mob could be thin. A posse needed a lawful reason and an officer to lead it, but in practice armed citizens sometimes took the law into their own hands, and historians of frontier lynching have counted some posses alongside vigilance committees and "people's courts". For that side of the story, see Vigilantism.

The Posse Comitatus Act

In 1878 Congress passed the Posse Comitatus Act, which bars the US Army (and, as later extended, the other armed services) from acting as a posse or doing ordinary police work without the approval of Congress. On the frontier this meant a marshal or sheriff could not simply order nearby soldiers to help him, although an off-duty soldier in civilian clothes could volunteer as a private citizen.

The posse on screen

The pursuing posse is a stock scene of countless Westerns. One of the most famous is the hand-picked squad of lawmen, hired by the railway boss E. H. Harriman, that hunts the outlaws in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969). Hang 'Em High (1968) opens the other way round, with a self-appointed posse hanging a man it wrongly believes is a rustler and killer.

See also

Key facts

Sources

  1. Posse comitatus - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
  2. Wikidata: Q643273 wikidata.org
  3. Wikimedia Commons: Ruby Murders posse and two prisoners.jpg commons.wikimedia.org