✦ Legend
Belle Starr (1848–1889), born Myra Maybelle Shirley, was a Missouri-born woman who mixed with outlaws for most of her adult life and became famous as "the Bandit Queen" only after she was shot dead in an ambush in 1889. Within months a New York publisher had turned her into "the Female Jesse James" in a dime novel, and the legend has outrun the evidence ever since. The only crime she was convicted of was larceny, at Fort Smith in 1883 (the charge involved stolen horses, according to later accounts).
Early life
She was born on 5 February 1848 on her father's farm near Carthage, in Jasper County, Missouri. Her father, John Shirley, later kept a livery stable in Carthage, and she was educated at the Carthage Female Academy, where she learned piano. During the Civil War her older brother John A. M. "Bud" Shirley fought as a Confederate bushwhacker. She may have helped him, perhaps as a spy, but this is unproven. Bud was killed by federal troops in 1864, and the family moved to Scyene, Texas, near Dallas.
Marriages and the outlaw world
On 1 November 1866 she married James C. Reed, a former member of Quantrill's guerrillas. They had two children, Rosie Lee ("Pearl") and James Edwin ("Eddie"). Reed turned to crime and was killed in August 1874 while resisting arrest. In April 1874 a warrant had been issued for Belle over a stagecoach robbery, although there was no evidence against her.
In 1880 she married Sam Starr, a Cherokee, and they settled on Cherokee Nation land at Youngers' Bend, near present-day Eufaula, Oklahoma. Their cabin served as a hideout for outlaws. She is also said to have organised and fenced for rustlers, horse thieves and bootleggers.
Conviction
Belle and Sam were charged with larceny in 1882 (the charge involved stolen horses, according to later accounts) and tried before Judge Isaac C. Parker at Fort Smith, Arkansas. The year is given differently: some accounts date the theft to 1882, others give the conviction as 1883. A court order dated 19 February 1883 already records the guilty verdict, so both are right; some later accounts give 8 March 1883. She served nine months in the Detroit House of Correction. In 1886 she escaped conviction on another theft charge, and in December that year Sam Starr was killed in a gunfight. She later married a younger relative of Sam's, Jim July Starr.
Murder
On 3 February 1889, two days before her 41st birthday, she was ambushed while riding home near Hoyt, Indian Territory, and killed by shotgun wounds. Her killing has never been officially solved. Suspects included her husband, both her children and a neighbour, Edgar J. Watson, who was tried for the murder and acquitted. One later account claimed Watson was convicted and hanged, but the record shows he was acquitted. She was buried at Youngers' Bend. The place of death is given differently: accounts differ: some say Hoyt, others Eufaula.
Legend versus history
- The Bandit Queen. She was little known outside Texas in her lifetime. In 1889 Richard K. Fox, publisher of the National Police Gazette, issued Bella Starr, the Bandit Queen, or the Female Jesse James, a largely fictional novel that is still sometimes cited as history.
- Jesse James and the Youngers. She knew members of the James–Younger Gang, but the stories that she married Cole Younger's uncle, or that her daughter Pearl was Cole Younger's child, are unsubstantiated. Younger himself dismissed the latter as rubbish.
- The image. She is described as a crack shot who rode side-saddle in a black velvet habit and a plumed hat, carrying two pistols. That image fed the legend, but the only crime she was convicted of is larceny (the charge involved stolen horses, according to later accounts).
- Shot with her own gun? A story that she was killed with her own double-barrelled shotgun is legend only.
On screen
Hollywood took up the Bandit Queen enthusiastically, with little regard for the facts. Gene Tierney played her in Belle Starr (1941), which made no pretence of accuracy but was a success. Jane Russell took the role in Montana Belle (1952), and Pamela Reed played her in Walter Hill's The Long Riders (1980), about the James–Younger Gang.
Key facts
- Born: 5 February 1848, near Carthage, Jasper County, Missouri, US
- Died: 3 February 1889, Hoyt, Indian Territory (now Oklahoma); some accounts give Eufaula
- Birth name: Myra Maybelle Shirley
- Spouses: James C. Reed; Sam Starr; Jim July Starr
- Only conviction: larceny at Fort Smith (charged 1882; convicted 1883; the charge involved stolen horses, according to later accounts)
- Nickname: "the Bandit Queen"
- Born 5 February 1848, Jasper County, Missouri (Wikidata); died 3 February 1889, Hoyt, Indian Territory (Wikipedia infobox; Wikidata gives Eufaula)
- Convicted of larceny at Fort Smith in 1883 (the charge involved stolen horses, according to later accounts)
See also
Gallery 8








Sources
- Belle Starr - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q238789 wikidata.org
- Wikimedia Commons: Woolaroc - Belle Star 2.jpg commons.wikimedia.org
- Belle Starr encyclopediaofarkansas.net
- Women and the Federal Court nps.gov
- Fact & Fiction: Popular Western Imagery from the Glenn D. Shirley Collection nationalcowboymuseum.org
- Court order sending Belle and Sam Starr to jail, 19 February 1883 (U.S. District Court, Western District of Arkansas, Fort Smith, defendant jacket 170) archives.gov

