Top 10 Revisionist Westerns
Ranked by True Grit score, then IMDb votes. TV series are listed under TV, not here.








2007 · 2 h 40 minDir. Andrew DominikTrue Grit 99, Gold
About Revisionist Westerns
From the wiki's article on the genre.
It is also called the post-classical or "postwestern" Western. Revisionist touches appear in films from the early 20th century, but the decisive shift is usually dated to 1968, when the Hays Code restrictions were relaxed, and revisionism has dominated Western film-making since 1969.
Traditional and revisionist
The traditional Western usually has a strong male lead, often a lawman or cavalry officer, who acts on behalf of "civilised" townsfolk and travellers against outlaws or Native American war parties. The revisionist Western subverts that pattern. It might make a Native American, an outlaw or a woman the protagonist, focus on survival in a wild land, or tell a morally ambiguous story with an anti-hero or a sympathetic villain. The aim is to blur the old boundary between the good guy and the bad guy.
Psychological Westerns
Opinion is divided on where revisionism began. Some 1930s films already had a darker edge, such as John Wayne's Westward Ho (1935), in which the hero leads vigilantes on a quest for revenge. The psychological Western, which put character ahead of action, began in the 1940s and was hugely popular through the 1950s and 1960s. Early examples include William A. Wellman's The Ox-Bow Incident (1943), a study of mob justice, and Henry King's The Gunfighter (1950), with Gregory Peck as an ageing gunman whose reputation follows him everywhere.
George Stevens's Shane (1953) is a classic case. The critic Kim Newman notes that its drifter hero enters a world of "believable characters with mixed motives", where even the villainous rancher has a point. Yet it ends with a conventional shoot-out, softened by Shane's admission that his day as a gunfighter is over. Anthony Mann's Westerns with James Stewart, such as Winchester '73 (1950) and The Naked Spur (1953), are also tagged as revisionist here, and High Noon (1952) was one of several 1950s Westerns that tried to strike back against the Hollywood blacklist.
Continue reading · 4 more sections
Indian Westerns
The Indian Western set out to reverse negative stereotypes by showing Native Americans sympathetically. Delmer Daves's Broken Arrow (1950), with Jeff Chandler as Cochise, was the breakthrough. Newman wrote that afterwards "it became fashionable for Westerns to be pro-Indian", although Native heroes were usually played by white actors. John Ford took a more critical look at the frontier in Sergeant Rutledge (1960), about a Black cavalry sergeant facing a court-martial, and Cheyenne Autumn (1964), his elegy for Native Americans mistreated by the government and misrepresented in his own films. Critics have also read The Searchers (1956) as exposing the racism and violence beneath its hero's surface.
The spaghetti Westerns
Free of the Hays Code and American expectations, the spaghetti Westerns were strongly revisionist from the start. Sergio Leone's A Fistful of Dollars (1964) made Clint Eastwood's Man with No Name the model for a morally ambivalent gunfighter copied again and again. In Leone's Once Upon a Time in the West (1968), it is not the gunfighters who inherit the West but the former prostitute Jill, who builds a town.
New Hollywood
As the Hays Code loosened, New Hollywood directors took up the Western. Sam Peckinpah's The Wild Bunch (1969) became controversial for its graphic violence, George Roy Hill made Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969), and Robert Altman made McCabe & Mrs. Miller (1971). The term "anti-Western" is used for especially gruesome or nihilistic examples.
Later revisionist Westerns
Eastwood carried the approach into his own films as director, from The Outlaw Josey Wales (1976) to Unforgiven (1992). Kevin Costner's Dances with Wolves (1990) follows a Union lieutenant who comes to live among the Lakota. More recent examples include Andrew Dominik's The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007) and Quentin Tarantino's Django Unchained (2012). The approach also runs into the neo-Western, as in the Coen brothers' adaptation of Cormac McCarthy, No Country for Old Men (2007).
All 135 films
Every film tagged Revisionist Westerns, in the same order. Films not yet rated on True Grit come last.
Show the other 125 films
- 11True Grit 99, Gold
- 12True Grit 99, Gold
- 13True Grit 99, Gold
- 14True Grit 99, Gold
- 15True Grit 99, Gold
- 16True Grit 99, Gold
- 17True Grit 99, Gold
- 18True Grit 99, Gold
- 19True Grit 99, Gold
- 20True Grit 99, Gold
- 21True Grit 99, Gold
- 22True Grit 99, Gold
- 23True Grit 99, Gold
- 24True Grit 99, Gold
- 25True Grit 99, Gold
- 26True Grit 99, Gold
- 27True Grit 99, Gold
- 28True Grit 99, Gold
- 29True Grit 99, Gold
- 30True Grit 99, Gold
- 31True Grit 99, Gold
- 32True Grit 99, Gold
- 33True Grit 99, Gold
- 34True Grit 99, Gold
- 35True Grit 99, Gold
- 36True Grit 99, Gold
- 37True Grit 99, Gold
- 38True Grit 99, Gold
- 39True Grit 99, Gold
- 40True Grit 99, Gold
- 41True Grit 99, Gold
- 42True Grit 99, Gold
- 43True Grit 99, Gold
- 44True Grit 99, Gold
- 45True Grit 99, Gold
- 46True Grit 99, Gold
- 47True Grit 99, Gold
- 48True Grit 99, Gold
- 49True Grit 99, Gold
- 50True Grit 99, Gold
- 51True Grit 99, Gold
- 52True Grit 99, Gold
- 53True Grit 99, Gold
- 54True Grit 99, Gold
- 55True Grit 99, Gold
- 56True Grit 99, Gold
- 57True Grit 99, Gold
- 58True Grit 99, Gold
- 59True Grit 99, Gold
- 60True Grit 99, Gold
- 61True Grit 99, Gold
- 62True Grit 99, Gold
- 63True Grit 99, Gold
- 64True Grit 99, Gold
- 65True Grit 99, Gold
- 66True Grit 99, Gold
- 67True Grit 99, Gold
- 68True Grit 99, Gold
- 69True Grit 99, Gold
- 70True Grit 99, Gold
- 71True Grit 99, Gold
- 72True Grit 99, Gold
- 73True Grit 99, Gold
- 74True Grit 99, Gold
- 75True Grit 99, Gold
- 76True Grit 99, Gold
- 77True Grit 99, Gold
- 78True Grit 99, Gold
- 79True Grit 99, Gold
- 80True Grit 99, Gold
- 81True Grit 99, Gold
- 82True Grit 99, Gold
- 83True Grit 99, Gold
- 84True Grit 99, Gold
- 85True Grit 99, Gold
- 86True Grit 99, Gold
- 87True Grit 99, Gold
- 88True Grit 99, Gold
- 89True Grit 99, Gold
- 90True Grit 99, Gold
- 91True Grit 99, Gold
- 92True Grit 99, Gold
- 93True Grit 99, Gold
- 94True Grit 99, Gold
- 95True Grit 99, Gold
- 96True Grit 99, Gold
- 97True Grit 99, Gold
- 98True Grit 99, Gold
- 99True Grit 99, Gold
- 100True Grit 99, Gold
- 101True Grit 99, Gold
- 102True Grit 94, Gold
- 103True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 104True Grit 84, Silver
- 105True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 106True Grit 84, Silver
- 107True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 108True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 109True Grit 84, Silver
- 110True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 111True Grit 84, Silver
- 112True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 113True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 114True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 115True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 116True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 117True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 118True Grit 84, Silver (provisional)
- 119True Grit 73, Silver
- 120True Grit 70, Silver
- 121True Grit 70, Silver
- 122True Grit 70, Silver
- 123True Grit 70, Silver
- 124True Grit 70, Silver
- 125True Grit 70, Silver
- 126True Grit 70, Silver
- 127True Grit 70, Silver
- 128True Grit 70, Silver
- 129True Grit 63, Bronze
- 130True Grit 55, Bronze
- 131True Grit 48, Bronze
- 132True Grit 48, Bronze (provisional)
- 133True Grit 41, Bronze
- 134True Grit 40, Bronze
- 135True Grit 0, Coal (provisional)
Related sub-genres
- Spaghetti Westerns167 films · 34 classicsSpaghetti Westerns were European-made Westerns, mostly Italian-led and often Italian-Spanish co-productions, that took off after Sergio Leone's A Fistful of Dollars (1964).Top rated: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (1966)
- Acid Westerns9 films · 5 classicsA strand of the Western from the 1960s and 1970s that mixed the ambitions of acclaimed Westerns such as Shane and The Searchers with the excesses of the spaghetti Western, coloured by the counterculture and drug culture of the time.Top rated: Wild Bill (1995)
- Neo-Westernscontemporary Westerns36 films · 1 classicsWesterns set in modern times that keep the Old West's themes and figures: the rebellious antihero, open plains and desert, and gunfights.Top rated: The Treasure of the Sierra Madre (1948)
- American Westerns745 films · 304 classicsWesterns made in the United States, where the genre began.Top rated: True Grit (2010)
- B Westerns and singing cowboys20 films · 13 classicsLow-budget Westerns made in large numbers to fill the lower half of double bills, chiefly from the 1920s to the 1940s.Top rated: Dark Command (1940)
- Cavalry Westerns46 films · 19 classicsWesterns centred on the US Cavalry on the frontier, such as John Ford's 'cavalry trilogy' of Fort Apache, She Wore a Yellow Ribbon and Rio Grande.Top rated: Fort Apache (1948)
Member reviews
What members think. Member reviews never change the True Grit score. The True Grit score is worked out by the editors from sources.
Sources
How well sourced: 2 sources (1 independent; Wikipedia and Wikidata count as one). See sources.
- Revisionist Western - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q491158 wikidata.org

































































































































