Hanging judge
A hanging judge is a judge with a name for sentencing many people to death by hanging, or for handing out unusually harsh punishments. Unlike a lynch mob or a vigilance committee, a hanging judge acted through the lawful courts: the accused had a trial, a jury and the right to a defence. In the Old West the title belongs above all to Isaac C. Parker, the federal judge at Fort Smith, Arkansas, who sentenced 160 people to death between 1875 and 1896, though he himself disliked the name and the real story of his court is more complicated than the legend.
The idea
The phrase is older than the American frontier. In English history the best-known "hanging judge" was George Jeffreys, whose "Bloody Assizes" after the Monmouth Rebellion of 1685 sent somewhere between about 150 and 300 men to the gallows; accounts differ. In the American West the term was used for any judge who seemed quick to pass the death sentence, and newspapers applied it freely. It was often unfair: in many places and for many crimes the death penalty was fixed by law, and the judge had no choice once a jury had found the prisoner guilty.
Isaac Parker of Fort Smith
Isaac Charles Parker (1838–1896), an Ohio-born lawyer and former congressman, was appointed by President Ulysses S. Grant in 1875 to the federal court for the Western District of Arkansas, at Fort Smith. The court had been badly run, and its reach was enormous: besides western Arkansas, it covered the whole of Indian Territory, some 74,000 square miles, wherever a crime involved someone who was not a member of the tribes. The territory had become a refuge for outlaws and whisky runners, and Parker's deputies, among them Bass Reeves, rode out across it to bring prisoners back for trial (see United States Marshals Service).
In his first term of court eight men were convicted of murder, and six were hanged together on 3 September 1875 before a large crowd. Over 21 years Parker's court heard more than 13,000 cases. He sentenced 160 people to death, including four women, and 79 men were hanged (accounts differ on the totals: figures published at his death gave 151 convicted of capital crimes and 84 hanged); the rest died in jail, were pardoned or had their sentences reduced, or won new trials on appeal. Among those hanged were the outlaw Cherokee Bill and members of the Rufus Buck Gang. The hangman George Maledon carried out many of the executions and became something of a celebrity.
Under federal law at the time, a jury's verdict of guilty of murder or rape carried a death sentence, so the sentence was not Parker's choice. For the first fourteen years of his time on the bench, his prisoners had no right of appeal. After 1889, when appeals were allowed, the Supreme Court overturned a number of his convictions, and Parker complained bitterly about the delays. In 1896 Congress removed Indian Territory from his court's jurisdiction. Parker was already very ill, and he died on 17 November 1896.
The man behind the name
Parker was a hard-working judge who took his duty seriously. "Permit no innocent man to be punished, but let no guilty man escape," he said he told his grand juries. "It is not I who hang men," he once said, "but the law." In an interview shortly before his death he said, "I never hung a man. It is the law," and he added that he would favour abolishing the death penalty if punishment could be made certain. He took an interest in reforming offenders and spoke up for the rights of the Indian nations under their treaties. On several occasions he petitioned the President for clemency for men he had sentenced.
Legend and history
- "The hanging judge". Parker was called "the hanging judge of Arkansas" in his own lifetime; Harper's Weekly used the phrase when he died, adding that he "did not like" it. The nickname is real, but it hides the mandatory death penalty and the long lists of his court's other work.
- Roy Bean. The saloon-keeper Roy Bean, "the Law West of the Pecos", is often called a hanging judge in films. He was only a justice of the peace, had no power to pass a death sentence, and never hanged anyone.
- The flowery death sentence. A famous mock death warrant, sentencing an imaginary "José Manuel Miguel Xavier Gonzales" in high-flown language, is often attributed to a frontier judge. It is folklore; no such case is known.
In Westerns
Parker's court at Fort Smith is where the hunt begins in True Grit (1969) and True Grit (2010), the judge himself appears in Rooster Cogburn (1975), and the stern judge in Hang 'Em High (1968) is loosely based on him. Bean's saloon justice is shown, partly for laughs, in The Westerner (1940) and The Life and Times of Judge Roy Bean (1972).
Key facts
- Meaning: a judge known for imposing many death sentences or very harsh punishments
- Best-known example: Judge Isaac C. Parker, Fort Smith, Arkansas (on the bench 1875–1896)
- Parker's record: 160 sentenced to death; 79 hanged
- Not to be confused with: lynch law and vigilance committees, which acted outside the courts
- Instance of: informal legal terminology (Wikidata P31)
- Isaac Parker: 160 sentenced to death, 79 hanged (Encyclopedia of Arkansas)
- Isaac Parker: 151 convicted of capital crimes, 84 hanged (Harper's Weekly, 28 Nov 1896)
See also
Sources
- Hanging judge - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q5648028 wikidata.org
- Harper's Weekly, 28 Nov 1896 (vol. 40, no. 2084), obituary of Judge Parker – Internet Archive archive.org
- “Parker, Isaac Charles” – CALS Encyclopedia of Arkansas encyclopediaofarkansas.net
- “Judge Isaac C. Parker” – Fort Smith National Historic Site (NPS) nps.gov
- NPS Fort Smith NHS, FAQ nps.gov
- Wikimedia Commons: John Michael Wright (1617-1694) - George Jeffreys, 1st Baron Jeffreys of Wem - NPG 6047 - National Portrait Gallery.jpg commons.wikimedia.org
