TheFrontierWiki
An almanac of the American West on page & screen
Sign in
People › Frontier folk › Corrupt lawmen and officials

Corrupt lawmen and officials

Usually bad · Part of Frontier folk

Some statements on this page are still being checked and are marked "Needs further sources".

✦ ✦ ✦
How well sourced: 2 sources. See sources.

The badge does not always stand for justice: some Westerns turn on the sheriff, judge or mayor who has been bought.

In classic Westerns

The corrupt lawman is the town boss's man, wearing a star but taking orders from the cattle baron or the saloon owner, like Sheriff Cobb in Silverado (1985). Crooked judges, mayors and Indian agents round out the type: men who use their office for profit, sell guns, steal supplies or rig trials. The hero must then stand for the law against the lawmen themselves.

  • Look: The same badge as the honest lawman, worn by a man who drinks with the villains.
  • Values: Self-interest; the law for sale.
  • Role in the story: A villain, or an obstacle the hero must get round.

Sub-types

Crooked sheriffs and marshals

Lawmen in the pay of the town boss or an outlaw gang.

The first jail in Broken Bow, Nebraska, 1886. A setting picture only: no one shown here is accused of anything.

The first jail in Broken Bow, Nebraska, 1886. A setting picture only: no one shown here is accused of anything.

Photograph · Solomon D. Butcher · 1886 · Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Broken_Bow%27s_First_Jail_1886.jpg · Licence: Public domain – UK: photographer Solomon D. Butcher died 1927, more than 70 years ago (CDPA 1988 s.12(2))

Corrupt officials, judges and agents

Mayors, judges, politicians and Indian agents who abuse their office.

The Custer County courthouse, Broken Bow, Nebraska, about 1900. A setting picture only.

The Custer County courthouse, Broken Bow, Nebraska, about 1900. A setting picture only.

Photograph · Solomon D. Butcher · c.1900 · Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Broken_Bow_Courthouse_ca.1900.jpg · Licence: Public domain – UK: photographer Solomon D. Butcher died 1927, more than 70 years ago (CDPA 1988 s.12(2))

In history

Documented history from period sources. The film portrayal is described above under "In classic Westerns"; this section is kept separate.

The best-known case is Henry Plummer, who became sheriff in Montana and was accused by the vigilantes of leading a gang of "road agents". The main source is the vigilantes' own history, written in 1866 to defend what they had done, so it gives one side only. (Needs further sources: the charge against Plummer is disputed and does not yet meet our rule of strong, independent evidence.)

Before Judge Isaac Parker came to the federal court at Fort Smith in 1875, its deputies had, in a modern historian's words, "a history of using perjury and bribery". (Needs further sources: one modern source; a period source is still needed.)

How the films differ

Films put a crooked sheriff in every other town. The record so far gives a few documented cases, and even the most famous, Plummer, is disputed.

Films

#FilmHow it qualifiesFrom the wiki's summary
1Shanghai Noon (2000)Crooked sheriffs and marshalsShanghai Noon (2000) is an action comedy, set in 19th-century Nevada, that combines the Western with a kung fu film.
2Open Range (2003)Crooked sheriffs and marshalsTwo cattlemen who drive their herds across open range, played by Robert Duvall and Kevin Costner, clash with a rancher who controls a nearby town.
3Young Guns (1988)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsA heavily fictionalised telling of Billy the Kid and the Regulators in New Mexico's Lincoln County War of 1878, with Emilio Estevez as Billy and a young cast that included Kiefer Sutherland, Lou Diamond Phillips and Charlie Sheen.
4Pale Rider (1985)Crooked sheriffs and marshalsA mysterious preacher rides into a mining camp and stands with the prospectors against a powerful rival.
5Fort Apache (1948)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsA proud, rule-bound colonel takes command of a remote Arizona cavalry post and clashes with his experienced captain over how to deal with the Apache.
6She Wore a Yellow Ribbon (1949)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsIn 1876, a veteran cavalry captain days from retirement leads one last patrol while trouble builds after Custer's defeat.
7Silverado (1985)Crooked sheriffs and marshalsLawrence Kasdan's Western ensemble stars Kevin Kline, Scott Glenn, Danny Glover and Kevin Costner.
8Rio Lobo (1970)Crooked sheriffs and marshalsAfter the Civil War, a former Union colonel sets out to find the traitor who sold secrets to the Confederates, a search that brings him to a Texas town run by crooks.
9Destry Rides Again (1939)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsA comedy Western in which a mild-mannered lawman takes on the crooks who run a rowdy frontier town.
10Chisum (1970)Crooked sheriffs and marshals; Corrupt officials, judges and agentsJohn Wayne plays the cattle baron John Chisum in a story based loosely on the Lincoln County War of 1878.
11The Life and Times of Judge Roy Bean (1972)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsJohn Huston's comedy-drama, from a John Milius script, loosely retells the life of the saloon keeper and self-appointed judge Roy Bean, played by Paul Newman, with Jacqueline Bisset, Ava Gardner and Huston himself.
12The Far Country (1954)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsA headstrong cattleman (James Stewart) drives a herd to Dawson in the Yukon and runs up against a corrupt judge.
13The Westerner (1940)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsA drifter befriends a self-appointed hanging judge in Vinegaroon, Texas, but opposes his campaign against homesteaders.
14They Died with Their Boots On (1941)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsErrol Flynn plays George Armstrong Custer, from his time as a cadet at West Point through the Civil War to the Battle of the Little Bighorn, with Olivia de Havilland and Arthur Kennedy.
15In a Valley of Violence (2016)Crooked sheriffs and marshalsA drifter and his dog arrive in a nearly deserted town, where a run-in with the marshal's son leads to bloodshed.
16Apache Rifles (1964)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsApache Rifles (1964) is a cavalry Western directed by William Witney, starring Audie Murphy as Captain Jeff Stanton, a renowned Indian fighter, with L. Q. Jones and Linda Lawson.
17The Dead Don't Hurt (2023)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsThe Dead Don't Hurt (2023) is a Western written, directed and produced by Viggo Mortensen, who also composed its score and co-stars alongside lead Vicky Krieps, with Solly McLeod, Garret Dillahunt and Danny Huston.
18Destry (1954)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsAudie Murphy plays a mild-mannered deputy who sets out to clean up a corrupt town without relying on his guns, with Mari Blanchard, Lyle Bettger and Thomas Mitchell.
19Young Billy Young (1969)Corrupt officials, judges and agentsYoung Billy Young (1969) is a Western directed by Burt Kennedy, starring Robert Mitchum as Deputy Ben Kane, with Angie Dickinson and Robert Walker Jr. in the title role, based on Heck Allen's novel Who Rides with Wyatt.
203 Bad Men (1926)Crooked sheriffs and marshalsA silent Western epic by John Ford, described by one critic as among his greatest silent epics.

Films are listed in order of popularity, with older classics given extra weight. Information courtesy of IMDb (https://www.imdb.com).

See also

Sources

  1. The Vigilantes of Montana (Thomas J. Dimsdale), Montana Post Press, Virginia City, 1866 (accessed 28 October 2026)
  2. U.S. Marshals and Deputy Marshals for the Western District of Arkansas, National Park Service, Fort Smith National Historic Site, n.d. (accessed 28 October 2026)