Lynch mobs and vigilantes
Usually bad · Part of Frontier folk
Some statements on this page are still being checked and are marked "Needs further sources".
When the law is far away or too slow, the Western shows ordinary townsmen turning into a mob with a rope.
In classic Westerns
The lynch mob is one of the genre's great moral tests. The classic picture is The Ox-Bow Incident (1943), where a posse hangs three innocent men; in many other films the sheriff stands alone in the jailhouse door to keep his prisoner for a fair trial. Vigilance committees are shown more ambiguously: sometimes as citizens cleaning up an outlaw town, sometimes as night riders serving a rich man's ends.
- Look: Torches, a rope over a cottonwood branch, a crowd outside the jail.
- Values: Rough justice in place of due process; the films almost always side with the law.
- Role in the story: The test of the lawman's courage and the town's conscience.
Sub-types
Lynch mobs
Crowds that try to take a prisoner from the jail or hang a suspect without trial.
Vigilance committees and night riders
Organised vigilantes, from committees of safety to masked night riders.
In history
Documented history from period sources. The film portrayal is described above under "In classic Westerns"; this section is kept separate.
Vigilance committees arose where there were no working courts. The Montana committee had its own history written in 1866, defending its work against what it called Henry Plummer's "road agents"; it gives the committee's side only. (Needs further sources: independent sources on the Montana committee are still needed.)
A rancher in Dakota in the 1880s wrote that the vigilantes there "did their work thoroughly", but that towards the end they grew reckless, paid off private grudges and hanged men on slight provocation. (Needs further sources: one first-hand account.)
How the films differ
Films show vigilantes either as heroes or as pure lynch mobs. The first-hand account from Dakota shows that the same committee could be both.
Films
| # | Film | How it qualifies | From the wiki's summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hang 'Em High (1968) | Lynch mobs | Jed Cooper, an innocent man who survives a lynching, is hired as a deputy US marshal by a federal judge. |
| 2 | The Ox-Bow Incident (1943) | Lynch mobs; Vigilance committees and night riders | After news spreads that a rancher has been murdered and his cattle stolen, townspeople and drifting cowboys form a posse to catch the killers. |
| 3 | Young Guns (1988) | Vigilance committees and night riders | A heavily fictionalised telling of Billy the Kid and the Regulators in New Mexico's Lincoln County War of 1878, with Emilio Estevez as Billy and a young cast that included Kiefer Sutherland, Lou Diamond Phillips and Charlie Sheen. |
| 4 | The Sons of Katie Elder (1965) | Lynch mobs | Four brothers come home to their Texas town in 1898 for their mother's funeral, and begin to ask how she lost her ranch and how their father died. |
| 5 | Broken Arrow (1950) | Lynch mobs | Delmer Daves's revisionist Western, with James Stewart and Jeff Chandler, dramatises a story based on real historical figures. |
| 6 | Two Rode Together (1961) | Lynch mobs | John Ford directs James Stewart and Richard Widmark in a story drawn from Will Cook's 1959 novel Comanche Captives, with Shirley Jones, Linda Cristal and Andy Devine in support. |
| 7 | The Tin Star (1957) | Lynch mobs | The Tin Star (1957) is a VistaVision Western directed by Anthony Mann, starring Henry Fonda as the bounty hunter Morgan Hickman and Anthony Perkins as a young, inexperienced sheriff. |
| 8 | The Westerner (1940) | Lynch mobs | A drifter befriends a self-appointed hanging judge in Vinegaroon, Texas, but opposes his campaign against homesteaders. |
| 9 | Chato's Land (1972) | Lynch mobs | Chato's Land (1972) is a Western directed by Michael Winner, starring Charles Bronson as Chato, a half-Apache man who kills a local sheriff in self-defence and is hunted by a posse of former Confederates. |
| 10 | Heaven's Gate (1980) | Vigilance committees and night riders | Michael Cimino's epic is loosely based on the Johnson County War. |
| 11 | Dodge City (1939) | Lynch mobs | Dodge City (1939) is a Technicolor Western directed by Michael Curtiz, starring Errol Flynn as Wade Hatton, a Texas cattle agent who becomes sheriff to clean up lawless Dodge City, Kansas, with Olivia de Havilland and Ann Sheridan. |
| 12 | The Hanging Tree (1959) | Lynch mobs | The Hanging Tree (1959) is a Western directed by Delmer Daves from Dorothy M. Johnson's 1957 novelette, set in the Montana gold fields and following a doctor who saves a criminal from a lynch mob. |
| 13 | Ride in the Whirlwind (1966) | Lynch mobs; Vigilance committees and night riders | Three cowboys are mistaken for outlaws and have to go on the run. |
| 14 | 5 Card Stud (1968) | Lynch mobs | 5 Card Stud (1968) is a Western mystery directed by Henry Hathaway, starring Dean Martin as the gambler Van Morgan and Robert Mitchum as a preacher, with Inger Stevens. |
| 15 | Bad Girls (1994) | Lynch mobs | Four former prostitutes go on the run after a killing in self-defence and a prison escape, and soon find themselves up against bank robbers and Pinkerton detectives. |
| 16 | Cimarron (1960) | Lynch mobs | A restless adventurer and his wife join the Oklahoma Land Rush of 1889 and help build a frontier town over the decades that follow. |
| 17 | Western Union (1941) | Vigilance committees and night riders | Western Union (1941) is a Technicolor Western directed by Fritz Lang, starring Randolph Scott as Vance Shaw, a reformed outlaw who joins the crew building a telegraph line across the Great Plains in 1861, with Robert Young and Dean Jagger. |
| 18 | Face to Face (1967) | Vigilance committees and night riders | A sickly professor from the East, played by Gian Maria Volonté, falls in with a wanted outlaw, played by Tomas Milian, and changes as he does so. |
| 19 | Buck and the Preacher (1972) | Vigilance committees and night riders | After the Civil War, a wagon master guides freed slaves heading west and teams up with a con man posing as a preacher to protect them from raiders. |
| 20 | The Oklahoma Kid (1939) | Lynch mobs | The Oklahoma Kid (1939) is a Warner Bros. |
Films are listed in order of popularity, with older classics given extra weight. Information courtesy of IMDb (https://www.imdb.com).
See also
Sources
- Theodore Roosevelt: An Autobiography, Macmillan, New York, 1913 (accessed 28 October 2026)
- The Vigilantes of Montana (Thomas J. Dimsdale), Montana Post Press, Virginia City, 1866 (accessed 28 October 2026)
